WEBVTT 00:06.500 --> 00:09.370 To and. What. 00:12.770 --> 00:17.030 Think the singing joel whale are make sure three marks from on 00:17.030 --> 00:19.930 the previous their working sessions and then to be happy to take 00:19.930 --> 00:21.160 your questions to kitchen. 00:22.400 --> 00:27.130 Good evening and we have just two heritage all first ever and 00:27.130 --> 00:31.150 meeting of ministers that dedicated to cyber defense. 00:31.920 --> 00:37.200 And NATO over or a in protecting rights of computer systems. 00:38.530 --> 00:40.950 This is a serious that challenge. 00:42.170 --> 00:43.650 And we're taking it seriously. 00:45.130 --> 00:47.490 And because cyber-attacks. 00:48.000 --> 00:50.320 Are getting more common. 00:51.250 --> 00:52.560 More complex. 00:53.270 --> 00:54.340 And more dangerous. 00:55.610 --> 00:56.950 They come without warning. 00:57.640 --> 01:00.180 From anywhere in the worried. 01:01.400 --> 01:04.140 And they can have devastating. Consequences. 01:05.750 --> 01:09.320 We have NATO are already conferencing this threats. 01:11.030 --> 01:12.280 Last year alone. 01:13.340 --> 01:18.630 At we don't with over are taught assassin five hundred it significant. Cases. 01:20.290 --> 01:21.080 That this one. 01:22.030 --> 01:26.430 Every three hours day and night every day of the. Year. 01:29.180 --> 01:34.120 Despite is each increasing. Sophistication are these attacks. 01:34.780 --> 01:38.910 And Our security has not been. Compromised. 01:41.500 --> 01:42.380 Protecting of. 01:42.900 --> 01:47.130 Our networks is shipmates roche their primary. Task. 01:49.800 --> 01:51.360 And that this the minimum. 01:51.870 --> 01:56.370 Bear we should aim for show today we have agreed. 01:56.900 --> 01:58.260 How we can more forward. 01:58.840 --> 02:01.350 In cyber defense as an. Alliance. 02:03.190 --> 02:04.780 We all closely connected. 02:05.560 --> 02:08.370 So an attack on one ally. 02:09.560 --> 02:13.400 Is not even up there was pretty and effectively can affect us all. 02:15.030 --> 02:21.300 A cyber defense is only as effective as the weakest link in the chain. 02:22.350 --> 02:23.660 By working together. 02:24.310 --> 02:26.220 We strengthen the chain. 02:28.390 --> 02:30.040 We all agreed that. 02:30.600 --> 02:32.500 Our cyber defense capability. 02:33.030 --> 02:36.690 Should be forty operation are by you what some. 02:37.760 --> 02:43.890 Extending. And our protection talk or the networks owned and 02:44.270 --> 02:46.950 operated at by the. Alliance. 02:49.080 --> 02:53.410 We or a great that are so I buddy finished came ability. 02:54.140 --> 02:55.200 And then. 02:55.840 --> 03:00.260 They're took the end and we agreed barely that we will of. 03:01.180 --> 03:06.600 Continue the all office question there at our next meeting bear 03:06.630 --> 03:12.330 in october up on how on they told ken support there and assist 03:12.360 --> 03:17.680 allies paul request assistance that if they come on the sibat tech. 03:18.670 --> 03:19.730 We were door that. 03:20.530 --> 03:24.410 On the basis all that detail three porch that we have tasked 03:24.530 --> 03:25.280 their today. 03:26.300 --> 03:28.060 And. Cyber-Attacks. 03:29.110 --> 03:31.350 Do not stop at national borders. 03:32.310 --> 03:34.990 Our defenses should not. Either. 03:37.730 --> 03:42.430 Today we or so this car such at how to make sure this alliance 03:42.470 --> 03:45.430 has the for a range of capabilities we need. 03:45.970 --> 03:49.350 To deal with afford range off threats. 03:50.810 --> 03:51.990 Defense budgets. 03:52.700 --> 03:53.460 Are forum. 03:54.110 --> 03:57.350 And the quest of modern capabilities is. Rising. 03:59.670 --> 04:01.130 There is an imbalance. 04:01.980 --> 04:04.430 Between the What we have. 04:04.940 --> 04:06.040 And what we need. 04:06.680 --> 04:11.030 Them which is significant short force in chomp areas such as 04:11.110 --> 04:12.410 a actual air refueling. 04:13.140 --> 04:16.030 There and intended and surveillance and reconnaissance. 04:17.030 --> 04:21.690 Am and there is an imbalance between the barkin carried thereby 04:21.720 --> 04:23.020 in debique your. Allies. 04:25.200 --> 04:27.600 These are challenge is we are address in. 04:28.610 --> 04:29.870 But we need to dorm all. 04:30.880 --> 04:32.120 There is a low limits. 04:32.700 --> 04:36.170 Fall what we can spend. On defense. 04:37.090 --> 04:40.120 Any some cases we have now rates dipped. 04:42.300 --> 04:43.600 To reverse that trend. 04:44.530 --> 04:47.540 We must put the line on defense spending. 04:48.500 --> 04:50.710 And look chill increase it. 04:51.280 --> 04:53.710 As our economy is recalled or. 04:55.790 --> 04:59.170 We must should make the best you wish other money. We have. 05:00.000 --> 05:01.500 Thrall better. 05:02.100 --> 05:03.870 Smock tough corporation. 05:05.270 --> 05:07.600 And european countries must do more. 05:08.360 --> 05:12.290 Virtual relieves the army put are button at which is currently 05:12.290 --> 05:15.610 being carried and by the United States. 05:17.330 --> 05:21.730 Some european countries are already increasing their spending. 05:22.370 --> 05:23.950 That despite the crisis. 05:25.030 --> 05:27.080 Or have committed to do all strong. 05:28.000 --> 05:33.590 And to date and number all of the ministers expressed their interest in. 05:34.160 --> 05:37.430 And further march a national or a projects. 05:38.120 --> 05:40.790 Better feel some of the gaps that we face. 05:42.430 --> 05:44.320 These are steps in the right direction. 05:45.290 --> 05:46.640 And I wellcome them. 05:49.000 --> 05:50.790 And try wrong or more below the be. 05:51.730 --> 05:55.380 Les amend mef. The premium and you study beyond that there monday 05:55.380 --> 05:59.670 and opt our. At that would essentially the donnie on maybe shoot 05:59.670 --> 06:03.960 or lack press Jong deforested the security their master no. 06:05.140 --> 06:08.850 Look counties polar done set domain that didn't expect he's a 06:09.330 --> 06:10.510 and it sounds a guided. 06:11.890 --> 06:14.970 Acrimony a sure could this Wesson gonna. 06:16.090 --> 06:20.270 Yeah. And a day Sally ye on the Seagate than void year. 06:20.720 --> 06:23.620 There in in the dilly guess shown picks payout and the be. 06:24.450 --> 06:28.240 Afront devil our commander looked and pull that right port or 06:28.270 --> 06:30.320 or mere S it bemoaned. 06:31.370 --> 06:32.190 He minis for. 06:33.580 --> 06:36.710 Shirt feely seeped dust. It. This is your. 06:37.700 --> 06:39.600 Interested attenborough or. 06:40.250 --> 06:43.990 At they are tele the pull water. It semi may at and she them 06:43.990 --> 06:48.000 under up or david. Yes you're at the set deluca shown donley. 06:48.000 --> 06:49.080 So men have in the 06:50.890 --> 06:54.220 And with that I'm ready to take your questions of. 06:55.070 --> 06:59.240 Will go and to the second row here please just movement time 06:59.720 --> 07:03.110 like man can you tell you please why a was CERN agreement not 07:03.110 --> 07:06.640 reached to allow always outside the protection to allies from 07:06.640 --> 07:09.710 the rapid reaction team in this meeting and it what we're the 07:09.710 --> 07:13.370 arguments against allowing that's record corrections force to 07:13.370 --> 07:14.710 be shared around the elyse. 07:15.360 --> 07:18.000 People to introduce just right then pharma from the telegraph. 07:19.580 --> 07:24.860 Actually we adopted that the progress report today. I am. 07:25.460 --> 07:30.040 A it in in in in that progress would ports that we describe. 07:30.630 --> 07:37.310 And the way forward you should look at this as a faced approach. 07:38.040 --> 07:41.840 We adopted them better keady concept in this bond in november 07:41.840 --> 07:45.270 two thousand ten and we stay teeth that we would strengthen said 07:45.270 --> 07:47.540 the security and the first phase. 07:48.070 --> 07:55.390 Has been bed show their strengths and cyber security and as regards 07:55.470 --> 07:56.970 NATO ship own. 07:57.500 --> 07:58.570 Air networks. 07:59.530 --> 08:04.060 And then in today's pro that the progress report we have adopted 08:04.060 --> 08:05.970 today that we agreed. 08:06.500 --> 08:12.620 At to an established their rapid reaction teams ed that came 08:12.830 --> 08:16.840 back out protects that made chose bone systems. 08:17.370 --> 08:22.300 And it's that we in this age to obliquely out there for operational 08:22.300 --> 08:25.110 capability that off them. 08:25.680 --> 08:33.020 And They are firm and response that capability by auto one that 08:33.020 --> 08:33.470 they shia. 08:34.210 --> 08:39.120 So this is the first phase. Now second phase will be drill into 08:39.330 --> 08:43.050 how they tend the airlines respond. 08:43.690 --> 08:49.160 Fed talk requests they're from elyse that come on the upside 08:49.160 --> 08:53.750 biotech and here. We have Sever possibilities. Of course one 08:53.750 --> 08:58.230 possibility would be that to your wish the rapid reaction teams 08:58.230 --> 09:02.220 and so that they will focus on the protection oft NATO ship their 09:02.250 --> 09:03.110 own systems. 09:03.690 --> 09:04.420 About of course. 09:05.000 --> 09:09.010 When they have their they cook part of the or so be used beyond that. 09:09.930 --> 09:13.160 And other brice ability and and and that away we usually have 09:13.440 --> 09:17.960 allies in need that would be took it draw a national over the 09:17.990 --> 09:22.980 sidewalk assets. Air chilled talk help there and ally gave. 09:24.000 --> 09:28.390 If you from a huge I that and an example we decided that to help 09:28.740 --> 09:34.020 and That defense turkey against part of the attacks by deploying 09:34.370 --> 09:36.460 than an opaque truck mishaps. 09:37.030 --> 09:38.810 These are national assets. 09:39.390 --> 09:42.790 Fair in a similar way when it comes to shy about that you're 09:42.790 --> 09:46.530 could decide to a deployed national are cyber assets that to 09:46.530 --> 09:52.880 help there and I like now this is an issue took the X pro orford 09:52.880 --> 09:57.210 that during this second phase there are there are a sidewalk 09:57.210 --> 10:01.540 approach show. It's not not a surprise that that we're stay you 10:01.650 --> 10:06.340 considering these things because we have center options and today 10:06.410 --> 10:10.510 we had a very very interesting discussion on that on the same. 10:11.030 --> 10:15.240 There ministers I very open minded as to how it we chords that 10:15.240 --> 10:19.080 mall forward. So actually I'm very satisfied that we the discussion 10:19.250 --> 10:21.620 we had today and the progress we have made show for. 10:22.540 --> 10:23.670 German television please. 10:24.500 --> 10:28.440 And you can you dish from german television Bernstein Rasmussen 10:28.470 --> 10:32.160 and capabilities was one of the main issues today. 10:32.690 --> 10:36.110 And the german defense minister the dim is jedi came here and 10:36.110 --> 10:40.930 announced again vets germany has to glory of that drone program 10:41.010 --> 10:42.610 that it's called the you rot. 10:43.500 --> 10:48.390 Air will which impact influenced as a careful on the NATO program 10:48.390 --> 10:51.860 on the a G M. I'm the ags. 10:53.280 --> 10:59.200 An Mcm as best understand aids heard a mass. Yeah has or so declared. 10:59.730 --> 11:06.570 Day that the parade germany this stays committed to the ags project. 11:07.130 --> 11:10.330 I I wellcome that that that statement. 11:11.000 --> 11:15.860 There and day and let me stress and that term. 11:16.750 --> 11:19.520 The the ags fair project. 11:20.370 --> 11:26.440 Arm. Or Within the ags a project that we intend. 11:26.980 --> 11:30.160 To purchase paired. What is called the probe are hawk. 11:30.810 --> 11:32.450 That which is a different system. 11:33.040 --> 11:36.380 Air is tested and tried and they already. Fright. 11:39.530 --> 11:40.180 And beyond the 11:42.460 --> 11:46.190 I think you Terry until so then he rmc B S. I looking ahead to 11:46.190 --> 11:48.620 tomorrow and I realize you have a discuss this yet. But what 11:48.720 --> 11:52.780 what is your thinking on each arm. Proposals that's on maybe 11:52.780 --> 11:56.400 made by the United States to put to what they're calling a bridging 11:56.400 --> 12:00.770 force in Afghanistan and briefly after two thousand and fourteen 12:00.770 --> 12:05.080 to transition into the the post that combat operations. Era. 12:09.220 --> 12:09.920 Let me. 12:10.540 --> 12:11.490 Stress that. 12:12.190 --> 12:14.320 Arm within the NATO context. 12:15.000 --> 12:16.290 At we're discussing. 12:16.930 --> 12:17.740 The F. 12:18.910 --> 12:22.390 Post tours arson fourteen training mission with a name breast 12:22.390 --> 12:23.280 a look support. 12:24.280 --> 12:27.010 And we're currently planning that. 12:27.640 --> 12:28.700 The mission. 12:30.000 --> 12:34.630 Am tomorrow I would expect their. Ministers to. 12:35.200 --> 12:37.360 Their Adoption. 12:37.870 --> 12:42.470 And what we call the concepts of operations that we create which 12:42.470 --> 12:47.280 will create the framework for further pending there are of the 12:47.310 --> 12:49.630 that and a training and mission. 12:50.530 --> 12:54.340 In parallel of the Individual our. 12:54.870 --> 13:00.620 Nation's. Day of may ed pen pay their own by letter or. 13:01.270 --> 13:05.890 The arrangements and we is and the Afghan government. 13:06.500 --> 13:11.390 A home and about as far as that NATO is concerned that we are 13:11.390 --> 13:14.790 focusing on the rest are look support training mission which 13:14.790 --> 13:16.960 would be established from to soften. Fifty. 13:19.580 --> 13:20.050 Am from. 13:20.630 --> 13:24.040 A engaging corps for reticient sexually general of the a french 13:24.040 --> 13:27.760 foreign minister saying today that to fronted now certain that 13:27.760 --> 13:31.470 turn and nerve gas sharon. Well has been using share on several 13:31.470 --> 13:35.150 occasions and if you of your past comments and that you expect 13:35.150 --> 13:38.320 an immediate reaction from an trash community. If chemical weapons 13:38.320 --> 13:42.140 use was proven what Sergei think we what treasured when I expect 13:42.140 --> 13:44.810 from NATO oily resting trash community. Thank you. 13:45.830 --> 13:49.870 And and first award us the metro president we never comment on 13:49.900 --> 13:52.750 intelligence and for a report. 13:53.340 --> 13:56.630 That but needless to say that they E if. 13:57.180 --> 13:58.880 And chemical weapons. 13:59.460 --> 14:02.240 There have it being used. 14:02.760 --> 14:05.580 We strongly condemn such. 14:06.100 --> 14:10.800 The acts. That whether Might have their use them. 14:11.570 --> 14:19.850 And They cannot show far much charity about the detail urge circumstances. 14:20.380 --> 14:26.220 And A but obviously we strongly condemn a any you wish their 14:26.250 --> 14:27.800 off that chemical. Weapons. 14:31.530 --> 14:32.330 Japanese. Media. 14:35.260 --> 14:39.350 My name is not very attendees from japanese my resume idiot secretary Gerald. 14:39.660 --> 14:45.500 It's abort cyber defense or are you a presuming a corporation receive. 14:46.450 --> 14:51.260 Information technology industry would be in disposable indispensable 14:51.260 --> 14:56.580 or are work which are like to explain what car into corporation 14:56.860 --> 15:01.610 would it be possible was to your if I tea industry use for us 15:01.610 --> 15:04.850 Borrows the cyber difference across rooms and succumbed question 15:04.850 --> 15:09.160 is corporation west the you'll in order to employee to a deprecation 15:09.550 --> 15:12.710 or what kind of corporation their own to have been you. Mind. 15:15.130 --> 15:21.130 And on the letter obviously and According nation a between. 15:22.000 --> 15:23.820 Am NATO indy you. 15:24.420 --> 15:27.150 Is so walk most a importance. 15:27.750 --> 15:28.270 Or so. 15:28.830 --> 15:34.460 When you coms to and beside or go security and say it is the 15:34.490 --> 15:40.070 props the alfred the on going dialogue between and NATO and to 15:40.100 --> 15:40.970 the european union. 15:41.940 --> 15:43.560 As regards them. 15:44.070 --> 15:50.090 Corporation we is the private and business. Yes indeed that's important. 15:50.610 --> 15:51.580 Let me stress. 15:53.070 --> 15:57.760 At and through the foreign ministers agreed on that in today's 15:57.790 --> 15:58.400 a discussion. 15:59.140 --> 16:05.260 That our ponder departure is that cyber security is first and 16:05.260 --> 16:07.860 foremost and national are that responsibility. 16:08.580 --> 16:11.070 It is a responsibility for each. 16:11.760 --> 16:12.810 Individual or nation. 16:13.360 --> 16:20.270 And to tour it's the op most to protect and information and calm 16:20.270 --> 16:21.620 indication systems. 16:22.210 --> 16:23.810 And that in that respect. 16:24.420 --> 16:28.960 Air Corp between governments and the private sector. 16:29.500 --> 16:34.050 About is cruel ship. I fully agree and whenever. I discussed 16:34.050 --> 16:38.680 the skews use that we is the our allies they I E. 16:39.500 --> 16:45.310 Am get the information that they already engage the in and such 16:45.790 --> 16:49.360 a quite aberration and aways the that the private sector. 16:49.760 --> 16:54.370 Shop first and foremost this is a responsibility air for individual 16:54.370 --> 16:55.380 are and nations. 16:55.930 --> 17:00.020 At what we have discussed today that is what more could be done 17:00.400 --> 17:01.870 at at the NATO to. 17:03.320 --> 17:04.820 Question from Georgian media over their. 17:06.670 --> 17:09.300 That is to come tiniest every to immunosuppression. 17:09.910 --> 17:13.500 At admitted general secretary of just to christian surfer said 17:13.500 --> 17:16.290 both the year tomorrow will begin their to georgie of commie 17:16.290 --> 17:20.010 shaming team games Janeiro questions will be the there until 17:20.010 --> 17:25.600 I said measham and It's new face and what can you say about it 17:25.600 --> 17:29.790 georgia's role in they knew place in I summation and the second 17:29.790 --> 17:33.310 question will clear about the and do we to medal a dose said 17:33.340 --> 17:36.250 in norway there. That's the I cited. 17:37.100 --> 17:41.260 As a russia has to react to on the membership of eats neighbors 17:41.290 --> 17:45.790 into a thing a until aimed to fit a lunch meant change that parity 17:45.790 --> 17:47.690 of the distribution of the powers. 17:48.220 --> 17:53.160 A what can you say it your appreciation about cyst statement think. 17:54.280 --> 17:58.370 The first on merryn their the training mission and georgettes 17:58.480 --> 18:03.720 that has already announced the their dig your get intent straw 18:03.720 --> 18:04.390 country that. 18:05.000 --> 18:08.340 That sure the resolute support and mission. 18:08.870 --> 18:12.430 And after two thousand fourteen and this is a reason and a right 18:12.430 --> 18:19.880 york yet is already now that included the in them and decision-making 18:20.000 --> 18:24.130 and processes that when e-commerce to the planning pair of that 18:24.130 --> 18:28.340 that if you to the mission and I suppose that defense means that 18:28.340 --> 18:32.150 we reaffirmed tomorrow there that you're get intends that to 18:32.150 --> 18:35.900 contribute to the few to training mission in Afghanistan which 18:35.900 --> 18:36.890 we warmly welcome. 18:37.740 --> 18:39.070 Now and 18:40.800 --> 18:43.420 Am let me stress that. 18:44.350 --> 18:49.270 It is not for certain countries air to interfere and a within 18:49.270 --> 18:54.290 NATO decisions their on men and future member sheep's enlargement 18:54.320 --> 18:59.180 open door that policy that's a NATO decision and we adhere to 18:59.180 --> 19:00.470 the basic principle. 19:01.130 --> 19:03.930 That each in give the coordination. 19:04.530 --> 19:05.930 Has the right. 19:06.500 --> 19:10.350 Toward the side. It's alliance affiliation freely. 19:11.500 --> 19:14.190 I am the Show. 19:14.790 --> 19:18.250 This is a question to be addressed. 19:18.800 --> 19:23.810 That in the partnership that between that georgia and may until. 19:24.450 --> 19:28.110 You will recall or that already in two thousand eight at the 19:28.110 --> 19:31.860 NATO summit in bucharest. We stated that you're until we become 19:31.860 --> 19:33.010 a member of NATO. 19:33.790 --> 19:38.080 Of course provided they that georgie afford fear that the necessary 19:38.130 --> 19:38.910 a criteria. 19:39.590 --> 19:44.240 And we have established the and and and NATO georgia come mission 19:44.570 --> 19:50.310 and our partnership day with georgia and they takes place the 19:50.310 --> 19:55.590 within head that at NATO georgia commission and tomorrow we would 19:55.590 --> 19:58.980 have such a NATO georgia commission meeting by the way. 19:59.500 --> 20:04.260 Am the NATO council that we lead visit georgia and pricey ends 20:04.510 --> 20:09.530 of that this months and all of these activities there are part 20:09.580 --> 20:13.230 of our efforts there to assist georgia. 20:13.820 --> 20:19.100 And it in continuing the necessary and reforms at sure eventually 20:19.100 --> 20:21.810 for feel are at the necessary. Criteria. 20:23.710 --> 20:25.070 One last question of the 20:26.680 --> 20:30.510 A hundred. On monday a new the Pentagon channel. 20:31.810 --> 20:36.310 And new so does we'll do it newman report of an article monday 20:36.310 --> 20:39.930 ninteen drawn two thousand and eleven Wintel not. 20:40.620 --> 20:44.420 This airport was a Veracruz ago regarding the obeying estates 20:44.560 --> 20:45.120 they ask. 20:45.780 --> 20:49.570 Some of them as an out of cowman the found. So disruptor becoming 20:49.730 --> 20:53.640 and to the guided by the benning go Vermont who has although 20:53.640 --> 20:54.440 a defiant. 20:55.140 --> 20:56.670 Fried up six of them. 20:57.350 --> 20:58.580 Without any motive. 20:59.290 --> 21:03.620 The know these the situation the main obeying and now them therefore 21:03.620 --> 21:06.200 tumble logic support our without command's. 21:07.070 --> 21:08.900 And would be think about. This. 21:11.550 --> 21:16.730 Then we're of aid to do it give you a very brief for the the 21:16.760 --> 21:17.270 on so. 21:18.000 --> 21:24.580 And we Are confident the that albania that we live optional or. 21:25.240 --> 21:30.980 A her obligations a within and a until or sure that when you 21:30.980 --> 21:33.080 coms true that the security sector. 21:34.430 --> 21:36.690 We do have time for one last question at a Fiona. 21:38.230 --> 21:42.750 For you to keep from assisted oppressed area like the cyber defense 21:42.830 --> 21:48.500 from I was wondering arm of all what kind of responses for discussed 21:48.500 --> 21:50.700 in terms of you mentioned patriot missiles. 21:51.350 --> 21:54.890 Arm when it comes a cyber who defense I'd there. You quibble 21:54.890 --> 21:58.020 about patriot missiles that could be deployed in cyberspace. 21:58.120 --> 22:02.390 What what kind of responses are possible in case of a at they've 22:02.390 --> 22:02.980 an attack. 22:04.750 --> 22:09.200 Yeah well of that I think you appreciate that. I can go into 22:09.200 --> 22:13.690 details the on on that eventually that would of course or stroll 22:14.170 --> 22:19.820 and depends there on this peace iffy. I am have circumstances 22:20.250 --> 22:25.490 that what we have proven discussed today is that at a pull ludicrous 22:25.490 --> 22:31.890 but TV lever air hall that the alliance as such there can respond 22:31.890 --> 22:35.520 to tool part of their requests that from in DB2 allies eve. 22:35.520 --> 22:39.740 They come on back tech. We we didn't discuss technique a D chambers 22:40.050 --> 22:45.640 the apart. How big secondly head tool to react a E for the an 22:45.640 --> 22:50.520 ally their them is a shock get their to and set aside back tech. 22:51.360 --> 22:53.210 Thank you very much for shield from our morning..